The harsh world of new technologies: could ""Naukova dumka"" have survived?

Author(s) Collection number Pages Download abstract Download full text
Zelinska N. V. № 1 (89) 165-175 Image Image

The reasons behind the gradual decline and eventual cessation of activity of Naukova Dumka – arguably the oldest state publishing house in Ukraine – are examined in the broader context of the current state of Ukrainian academic science, the transformations in both global and domestic academic publishing, the inevitable impact of digital technologies on the publishing industry, and the pressing need to develop and apply PR strategies and effective methods for promoting academic books. Having started its work 102 years ago and having gone through various historical periods alongside the country, Naukova Dumka was long considered «a highly professional publishing institution with outstanding editorial schools across various scientific fields». However, this proved insufficient in the face of chronic underfunding, especially of its “parent” institution – the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. Moreover, the publishing house failed to properly integrate into the new system of media technologies, evidently overestimating the strength of the conservative academic tradition. Could the closure of this authoritative institution – more than just a well-known, recognizable brand, but a true “factory” of high-quality scholarly and reference publications – have been avoided? That question now belongs to history. A history that must not be repeated in the professional destiny of other publishing houses that, in today’s challenging times, continue to produce scholarly literature and must therefore more actively implement the unrealized opportunities that Naukova Dumka lost for various reasons (this includes, in particular, thorough research and segmentation of the potential readership; parallel preparation and sale of electronic versions of publications; active presence of the publishing house on social media; ongoing engagement in the life of the academic community, and so on.).

Keywords: science, scholarly book publishing, publishing, media technologies, marketing, promotion, PR communications, PR strategies, advertising, social networks.

doi: 10.32403/0554-4866-2025-1-89-165-175


  • 1. Texty.org.ua. (2024, November 29). 102-richne vydavnytstvo «Naukova dumka» likvidovuyutʹ za rishennyam NANU. https://texty.org.ua/fragments/113964/102-richne-vydavnyctvo-naukova-dumka-likvidovuyut-za-rishennya-nan/.
  • 2. Alekseiienko, I. (2022). Do 100-richchia vydavnytstva “Naukova dumka” NAN Ukrainy. Visnyk Kn. palaty, (8), 32–40.
  • 3. Lohvynenko, B. (2024, December 3). Vid Ahatanhela Krymsʹkoho tam vzhe hetʹ nichoho ne zalyshylosia. Tut budutʹ i dali konseruvaty sovok. Telegraf. https://news.telegraf.com.ua/ukr/blogi-mnenija/2024-12-03/5888698-vid-agatangela-krimskogo-tam-vzhe-get-nichogo-ne-zalishilosya-tut-budut-i-dali-konservuvati-sovok.
  • 4. Didenko Yu.V. Scientific periodicals of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine: blood, sweat and tears. Visn. Nac. Akad. Nauk Ukr. 2024. (8): 76–85. https://doi.org/10.15407/visn2024.08.076.
  • 5. Didenko, Yu. V., & Radchenko, A. I. (2022, Veresenʹ 3). Naukovo-vydavnycha diialʹnistʹ Natsionalʹnoi akademii nauk. https://nvd-nanu.org.ua/nvr/reports/.
  • 6. Natsionalʹna akademiia nauk Ukrainy. (2025). Zvit pro diialʹnistʹ Natsionalʹnoi akademii nauk Ukrainy u 2024 rotsi. Akademperiodyka. https://www.nas.gov.ua/storage/editor/files/zvit-2024-projekt.pdf.
  • 7. Kahamlyk, S. (n.d.). Naukovoiu dumkoiu bahatiiemo. https://chytomo.com/naukovoiu-dum­koiu-bahatiiemo/.
  • 8. Kvitko, I. S. (1995). Suchasnyi stan i perspektyvy rozvytku akademichnoho knyhovydannia v Ukraini. In Knyha i presa v konteksti kulturno-istorychnoho rozvytku ukrainsʹkoho suspilʹstva (pp. 20–32). Lviv.
  • 9. Masenko, L. (2024, February 1). Naukova dumka chy naukova Dunka? Ukrainian University Club. https://ukrainianuniversity.club/2024/02/01/наукова-думка-чи-наукова-дунька/.
  • 10. Ostapa, S. (2022, Hrudenʹ 26). Kilʹkistʹ vydanykh v Ukraini rosiisʹkomovnykh knyzhok zmenshylasia maizhe na 60%. Monitorynh roboty Derzhkomteleradio za druhe pivrichchia 2022 roku. Detector Media. https://detector.media/infospace/article/206338/2022-12-26-kilkist-vydanykh-v-ukraini-rosiyskomovnykh-knyzhok-zmenshylasya-mayzhe-na-60-monitoryng-roboty-derzhkomteleradio-za-druge-pivrichchya-2022-roku/.
  • 11. Petrenko-Tseunova, O. (2024, Hrudenʹ 1). Zakryttia “Naukovoi dumky”: reaktsii ta spohady. https://tyzhden.ua/zakryttia-naukovoi-dumky-reaktsii-ta-spohady/.
  • 12. Serdiuk, V. (2001). “Naukova dumka”: tvorchyi shliakh dovzhynoiu u visim desiatyrich. Visnyk Kn. palaty, (12), 4–8.
  • 13. Yatskiv, Ya. S., Vakarenko, O. H., & Didenko, Yu. V. (2023). Naukovo-vydavnycha diialʹnistʹ NAN Ukrainy v umovakh rosiisʹko-ukrainsʹkoi viiny. Visnyk NAN Ukrainy, (6), 100–105.
  • 14. Weingart, P., & Tauber, N. (Eds.). (2017). The future of scholarly publishing: Open access and the economics of digitisation. African Minds.
  • 15. Barker, R., & Escarpit, R. (Eds.). (1973). The book hunger. London: George G. Harrap & Company Ltd.
  • 16. Gotti, M. (2007). Globalization and discoursive changes in specialised context. In Discourse and contemporary social change (pp. 143–154). Peter Lang Group AG.
  • 17. Oparinde, K., Govender, V., Adedokun, T., & others. (2024). Key developments in global scholarly publishing: Negotiating a double-edged sword. Learned Publishing. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/379670325_Key_developments_in_global_scholarly_publishing_Negotiating_a_double-edged_sword.
  • 18. Lupova-Henry, E., & Tenorio-Forné, Á. (2021). Re-thinking academic publishing: The promise of platform cooperativism. Business of Knowing. https://doi.org/10.21428/6FFD8432.0ED64224.
  • 19. Thompson, J. B. (2005). Books in the digital age: The transformation of academic and higher education publishing in Britain and the United States. Cambridge University Press.
  • 20. Thompson, J. B. (2012). Merchants of culture: The publishing business in the twenty-first century (2nd ed.). Cambridge: Polity; New York: Penguin.